English rugby union's second-tier league, the Champ, is set to undergo a significant change in its bonus-point system, adopting a 'three tries more' rule that has been in place in France's Top 14 and Super Rugby for some time. This new system, which is expected to be implemented from the 2026-27 season, will reward teams for finishing games with three more tries than their opponents, rather than the current system where four or more tries earn a point regardless of the match outcome. The change has sparked debate, particularly after Bristol Bears secured a consolation point despite a heavy defeat to Northampton Saints, highlighting the current system's potential for encouraging high-scoring, one-sided matches.
The 'three tries more' rule is designed to incentivize defense and reduce the incentive for teams to relax once they've built a lead. In a recent match, Saracens would have finished with four match points instead of five if they had conceded twice in the final ten minutes, finishing with four tries to Gloucester's two. This rule has been in effect in the Top 14 since the 2014-15 season and in Super Rugby since 2016, with the Champ now following suit. The introduction of a play-off system for the top six teams, known as the 'barrages' in France, further mirrors French and Super Rugby structures.
The Champ's move to this system is part of a broader trend in rugby union to balance the game and encourage more competitive matches. The change comes as the sport seeks to address concerns about the current bonus-point system, which has been criticized for promoting high-scoring, one-sided games. The 'three tries more' rule is seen as a way to incentivize defense and create more competitive, evenly matched matches.
However, the transition to this new system is not without challenges. The final ratification from the RFU is required over the summer, and there are potential hurdles to overcome. Despite this, the plan is expected to be in place for the 2026-27 season, marking a significant shift in the structure of English rugby union's second tier. The Champ's adoption of the 'three tries more' rule is a response to the need for a more balanced and competitive system, reflecting the sport's ongoing evolution and the influence of international rugby structures.
